Gender critical lesbian discriminated against by local authority

by Lizzy Pitt

Gender critical lesbian discriminated against by local authority

by Lizzy Pitt
Lizzy Pitt
Case Owner
I qualified as a social worker in 2007. I'm currently employed as a Social Work Manager by Cambridgeshire County Council. I am a lesbian who believes that sex is binary and immutable.
Funded
on 21st October 2023
£51,529
pledged of £51,000 stretch target from 2121 pledges
Lizzy Pitt
Case Owner
I qualified as a social worker in 2007. I'm currently employed as a Social Work Manager by Cambridgeshire County Council. I am a lesbian who believes that sex is binary and immutable.

Latest: Aug. 1, 2024

Cambridgeshire County Council surenders!

 
 
 
 
 

Update on Gender critical lesbian discriminated against by local authority

 

Cambridgeshire County Council surrenders!

My hearing was due to start on Monday this week.…

Read more

I am a social worker, and a lesbian who believes that sex is real, and matters. Sex matters particularly to me as a woman who is exclusively sexually attracted to women. I do not believe that men can literally become women.

When I sought to participate in meetings of a workplace LGBTQIA group and expressed my “gender critical” belief, I was subjected to a group complaint by colleagues followed by a disciplinary process resulting in formal “management action” designed to silence me. I was also excluded from the network. The whole process was intensely stressful and humiliating for me. It left me feeling that my colleagues and my employer regarded me as a bigot who could only be tolerated in the workplace if I was forced to keep my beliefs to myself even when they were relevant.

I am aware of colleagues that share my view but are too afraid to speak out.

This kind of silencing and bullying is happening in local authorities, schools, colleges, universities, NHS trusts etc, up and down the country. A false consensus is imposed through a climate of fear. This has serious consequences for the way professionals like social workers, clinicians, teachers and others do their jobs - and serious consequences for the safeguarding of some of the most vulnerable in society.

It needs to stop. Will you help me to stop it?

I’m suing my employer, Cambridgeshire County Council (CCC), in the employment tribunal for harassment and discrimination. Employers won’t learn that this kind of behaviour is unacceptable unless they can see other employers being found liable by a tribunal and having to pay compensation. If you donate money to help me run this case, I understand that you’re doing so much more for the sake of that public example than to help me personally. I promise to give that fact full weight in any decision I make about settlement, and I promise I won’t settle on confidential terms unless I truly feel I have no alternative.

I am initially raising funds for legal representation for the Preliminary Hearing. The target for this stage of proceedings is £17,500.

I have a great legal team!

My Solicitor Liz McGlone,  Partner at Didlaw, who specialises in Employment Law.

My Barrister Naomi Cunningham,  Outer Temple Chambers, who specialises in Employment and Discrimination law

Please donate, if you can, and please circulate widely.

Your support would be greatly appreciated.

Get updates about this case

Subscribe to receive email updates from the case owner on the latest news about the case.

Recent contributions

Be a promoter

Your share on Facebook could raise £26 for the case

I'll share on Facebook
Update 7

Lizzy Pitt

Aug. 1, 2024

Cambridgeshire County Council surenders!

 
 
 
 
 

Update on Gender critical lesbian discriminated against by local authority

 

Cambridgeshire County Council surrenders!

My hearing was due to start on Monday this week. Thanks to you, my case was extremely  well-prepared, and my legal team was ready to ask the Council’s witnesses lots of hard questions. However, first thing on Monday morning, the Council’s solicitors told us that they were willing to admit that they had discriminated against me, and pay the compensation I had claimed in full. After some negotiation, they also agreed to a recommendation from the tribunal that they should add a compulsory module to their e-learning on freedom of belief and expression in the workplace. The module is to be written by the barrister Anya Palmer, which I consider a very welcome and important addition to all our council workers training in Cambridgeshire- thank you Naomi Cunningham for negotiating and holding out on that one.

We have made an application for an order that the Council pays all my legal costs, because their defense was always hopeless, and the tribunal’s decision on that application is awaited. I will inform when we have an outcome.

I am personally very disappointed with my ex-employer who held out to 8.38 on the morning of the hearing before conceding- this was a 10 month wait after they were served the original papers.  I say ex-employer as I gave immediate notice following a 9 month wait for a response to my grievance which was turned down flat.  They could not tell me what I had said or done that was 'transphobic', yet refused to remove it form my record.

We don’t know exactly why the Council decided to surrender at the very last minute, but we can speculate. The evidence in the case would have been, dare I say, embarrassing. Five of my colleagues had made a joint complaint about what I had said at a meeting of an LGBTQ+ Peer Support Group to punish me for expressing my everyday, mainstream belief in reality, that there are two sexes, and for having clear boundaries as a lesbian, about men in lesbian spaces. I also included online dating apps and in person social groups as areas that I want to be lesbian and women only- because yes, we all know what a lesbian is.

My colleagues' reactions to hearing views they disagreed with had been hysterical. One said that he couldn’t sleep for two nights “thinking about this cruelty”, and referred to my “symbolic violence," and then going full steam with just "violence”. Another said that he had felt able to relax at the beginning of the meeting because he thought “ah we’re all like minded friends here”- it’s an amusing irony of gender identity belief that it holds that “diversity” requires everyone to think the same. The same colleague said that by the end of the meeting he was “shaking in disbelief” and “traumatised". A third colleague said she had had several nights of poor sleep after the incident, and had continued to experience problems with sleeping and anxiety dreams.There was talk of one colleague's “gender-fluid” (clearly male) dog, which he puts in dresses. He had identified his dog as gender fluid, no self-id there then. (You really had to be there.)

So it would be understandable if, when it came to it, the Council’s witnesses may have felt a bit queasy about the questions they were likely to face, and for clarity the above is the tip of the iceberg. Let’s hope that other employers will start to learn that it’s a bad idea to try to stop lesbians asserting their boundaries and silence staff who know that sex is real, and sometimes matters.

I thank everybody for the support you have given to me- I have lots of thank you's still to do- there have been 2121 donations to the fund!, and this win belongs to all of us.

I especially thank Naomi Cunningham and Liz McGlone for their brilliance and recommend them wholeheartedly- although they will probably be too busy X 

now, I need a job (insert emoji)

Update 6

Lizzy Pitt

July 28, 2024

Employment Tribunal begins tomorrow Monday 29th July!

Hello everybody, again I thank you with much gratitude, together we have raised my target with 1000's of folk contributing. There have been amazing messages left in the funder, keeping me as positive as I can be ❤️

I had a hope of returning to work, naive perhaps, though positive and hopeful. However, on the 4th July I gave notice, as my grievance against the CCC grievance against me took over 7 months to complete and was not upheld in any way. 

Continuing to be labelled transphobic and silenced, for a lesbian social worker who has a regulatory body, and who works with the Equality Act in a meaningful and inclusive way has made it impossible for me to return. I am devastated by this although continue to think I have done the right thing. This fight is for all of us. 

So, tomorrow Court begins, I hold great store in my excellent legal team, though know it is the Law that will decide. 

I will keep you all posted and thank you so very much. Lizzy, 


Update 5

Lizzy Pitt

June 27, 2024

Continuing with the final push!

Hello, I continue to thank you all for your amazing support, it really means so much. 

My excellent, brilliant legal team of Liz McGlone - Didlaw, and Naomi Cunningham - Outer Temple Chambers are working very hard behind the scenes, there has been more work to do which means I have had to increase my target.  

The process is a difficult one, however I continue to know that I have chosen the right path. It is so important to stop our  statutory bodies discriminating on gender critical/sex realist grounds.  And as a lesbian I am same sex attracted,  I really do not believe I am  'transphobic' for saying so. 

Being harrassed and silenced has been very hard and not something any of us should have to accept from our statutory bodies.

I am hopeful for a positive outcome, as I would be, although recognise there is a long way to go.

Court begins 4 weeks on monday so its serious  countdown time now.

Please support my crowdfunder if you are able, and share widely with your networks.                        Thank you, Lizzy


 


Update 4

Lizzy Pitt

June 1, 2024

The final push!! ..... Court date29th July to 2nd August

Hello everybody, and again thank you for all the support you have given to me, I cannot tell you how much I appreciate it. 

The case is listed for 29th July to 2nd August in Cambridge, so very soon. 

My legal team is my solicitor Elizabeth McGlone and my Barrister Naomi Cunningham, they have been working very hard, and very skillfully behind the scenes, preparations are going well. 

You will understand that I am limited with what I can share, as soon as I can I will, and think you will be as shocked as I am about what has been said! 

So here goes again with the last push before Court, as I still have funds to raise before I get to Court.  It's taken a while to post this update as I find it so difficult to keep asking, but I must. 

This case is important for Social Work and social workers who work within a legal framework and have a responsibility to ask questions and seek information. 

It is also wider than Social Work, it will be important for all public servants and citizens in receipt of public services. I know the debate right now is how many cases? How many times?.  We will have to keep bringing these cases until the employers listen. 

Again, if you donate  to help me run this case, I recognise that you do so much more for the public example than to help me personally.  I promise to give that fact full weight in any decision I make about settlement, and I promise I won't on confidential terms unless I truly feel that I have no alternative. 

Please help me make Cambridgeshire County Council listen, and once they have councils through the land will have to do so too. 

If you can contribute or share widely I would be very grateful. 

Thank you again for all your support and good wishes which help me to keep going. 

Update 3

Lizzy Pitt

March 17, 2024

We now have a Court date!

Firstly I'd like to thank you all again for the support you have given to the case and therefore to me.  It has been agreed that the case will go forward, this is excellent news! 

The final hearing is set up for five days from the 29th July- 2nd August this year and will be in Cambridge. 

I now have to return to the Crowd Funder and continue to ask for support, I find this difficult although know its importance. 

Please could I ask that you contribute if you can-I know this is a big ask, and please if you can share as widely as you can I would be very grateful. 

I'm so thankful for the cases that have gone before mine and know that we must keep fighting.

 What should lawfully give us protections: the seminal  Forstater v CGD has yet to become understood and embedded by many employers. My intention is that this case will further the understanding of the law and hopefully mean that fewer people will be harrassed and discriminated against in the workplace - the purpose of this case. 

Thank you again for any support you are able to offer. 

Update 2

Lizzy Pitt

Feb. 26, 2024

We now have a preliminary Court date!

Hello everybody, firstly I'd like to thank you all again for the  amazing support you have given! 

It's coming up to 5 months!  which is a long time to wait for a preliminary hearing date. However the date has been confirmed and the case is listed for the 8th March 2024.  The purpose of the preliminary hearing is to identify the legal and factual issues the tribunal will be asked to decide. To list the case for hearing, if appropriate, and to make any further case management orders if needed going forward. 

I will update as soon as I have further information and once again I thank you all for your support. 

Update 1

Lizzy Pitt

Nov. 3, 2023

We now have the funds to support me through the preliminary hearing- thank you!

Firstly, I'd like to thank everybody so much for your support, the fund has met and exceeded its first target because of the fantastic response from you all!  I am truly grateful. 

We now have the funds to support me through a Preliminary Hearing as and when it is listed.  The claim has just been accepted and we now await the response from the Council.  I will update you when we have a date for the Preliminary Hearing.   

I see this case as another example of where employees working in the public sector are being silenced to such an extent that it impacts our work, compromises our professionalism and in contravention of the protections afforded under the Equality Act 2010.   I feel I have no other choice but to pursue this claim to shine a light on the treatment that public sector workers face in relation to the protection of their beliefs and also sexual orientation.   

I would be so grateful if you could continue to donate and share where you are able, and that you do so in the context of the case being for the benefit of all workers and especially those in the public sector.

Get updates about this case

Subscribe to receive email updates from the case owner on the latest news about the case.

    There are no public comments on this case page.